No Impact Man response

This was an interesting documentary, certainly worth watching.  I feel his efforts to live with no impact would have been much more effective and practical if he did not live in a major city, but the extreme of New York City as his setting served to make a point, demonstrating what can be done by the majority, those who live without much access to the natural world who typically have the most impact on the environment.  I really appreciate that it did not claim to be scientific or in any way an authority on its subject, despite its clear attempt at honesty.  The man seemed to make great efforts to remain sensible and down-to-earth, despite the extreme nature of his experiment, which gave the whole thing a kind of honest credibility.

Of the two people this film followed, I found the man to be quite relateable in his motives, practices, and execution, but found his wife to be absolutely intolerable.  The entire film I was trying to figure out what brought these two clearly incompatible people together, and hearing that they had separated after the film came as no surprise.  Maybe it has something to do with my upbringing, but I just can’t bring myself to understand her kind of manipulative, helpless victim, consumer mentality.

My family has always been environmentally conscious, regularly recycling, composting, almost never eating out, and enjoying many long camping excursions where we would separate ourselves from civilization entirely with no electricity, plumbing, or access to shopping centers, often eating fish that we had caught ourselves.  The few things we never gave up were toilet paper, meat, and sugary food.  Simply because I’ve never given these things up, I feel compelled to try living without them, though the idea going without toilet paper is a bit off-putting.  Given the minimal environmental impact of paper products, I feel this aspect of the experiment was a bit unnecessary but I noticed that they never really discussed their personal feelings about it, which is all the more strange.


One thought on “No Impact Man response

  1. My thoughts on No Impact Man are pretty similar to yours after finishing the documentary. I would have been very interested to see how the same experiment would look if he tried it out in the country–perhaps somewhere with a water source like a creek which the family could have used as a refrigerator among other things. It would have its own set of advantages and disadvantages to deal with, but I think it might be easier. I liked the fact that the man did seem so down to earth even if his idea was extreme. That made me much more willing to take him seriously, although I agree that the wife was much more off-putting for the majority of the documentary. I guess there relationship just goes to show how important it is to find like-minded and dedicated people to team up with when one wants to attempt something so life-changing?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s