Can killing be justified at all?

It’s been really helpful for me to watch this documentary, because it keeps raising some questions in my mind that sometimes I want to put on hold and forget about. I feel like the issue of dolphin slaughter in Taiji really speaks about much broader and at the same time more personal questions. The idea of killing anything for the sake of having something for oneself, or proving something to others, is a bothersome one. I’m thinking more and more that killing is not justified in any case, or for any reason. Many of us agree on that point concerning people, but we often don’t think that for animals. But how much is it really different? I understand that we as humans can relate to one another more, and we can accept each other as equals for the most part, but often we see people relating to animals just the same, or even much more than to other humans. And even though some people cannot understand each other, cannot relate and maybe cannot even see each other as equals, we still generally do not justify killing people. So, why can we justify killing in one sense, and not in the other?

For many years now, and especially since I came to the United States, which happened 3 and something years ago, I’ve been exposed to thinking about eating meat. When I lived my life in Belarus there seemed never be a question that it’s okay to kill animals in order to get food. I do remember seeing my dad cutting a chicken’s head off, and I don’t think I loved that experience too much, even though I do not think of it as a particularly dramatic one either. I also understand that this was the way to get food, and I had to eat, so I didn’t question it. However, when I came to the US and saw how much availability of different foods other than animal meat there is in the world, I started to think, why do I need to eat meat? 12255653_low

Of course, one may say if we stop killing animals, there will be too many of them on the Earth. But animals kill each other as well, so if we leave them alone and live our lives without touching them, they will be just doing their thing, regulating their populations, and evolving into higher species. It comes back to the question from the beginning of the semester about whether we should be part of the ecosystem. If yes, then it should be perfectly justified to kill other animals for food, or for other reasons, kill each other for survival, be wild, just as other animals are in ecosystems. But if we could detach ourselves gradually, we could let the nature and the ecosystems develop on its own without being disturbed by humans. And it seems like that’s what we are doing slowly.

I guess everything happens gradually, and we are learning things step by step. We are getting less cruel, more caring, first to ourselves, then to animals, and maybe to everything that surrounds us. Rick O’Barry is a perfect example. He was the one who started the whole thing with dolphins, yet he learnt that what was happening was not right, and now he is helping to turn things around. And even if it’s not happening fast, we also are learning from him, so the chain keeps going anyway, and eventually things maybe are not so bad as we think sometimes. I mean, if we think back 100 years ago, people were 100 times less caring about the environment, animals, each other. We are changing all the time, and this process can go only faster if we share the change with each other. 


4 thoughts on “Can killing be justified at all?

  1. Killing can be both good and bad. I wouldn’t say to go overboard with killing–that would cause massive population decrease–but limited to how much we should kill so we don’t have to be wasting tons of food.

  2. Hunters typically regulate the deer population, and end up doing them a great service. Without hunting, thousands of deer would starve to death from over population every year. So as much as people advocate the preservation of animals, sometimes the best way to keep that up is by thinning the population. Sure that’s interfering with the natural order of things, but we’ve already screwed that up, now haven’t we?

  3. Before you even got to the issue of this blog post, that first sentence really stuck out to me. I know exactly how you feel about putting feelings on hold or wanting to forget about certain things, and how grateful I am for the people who are spreading awareness. The dolphin slaughter that is still common practice is almost too horrible to even believe. But environmental issues, especially this one, won’t go away unless we delve into them–not avoid them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s